Is a Promise to Deed Property on a Scrap of Paper Good Enough to Be a Valid Contract?

Is a Promise to Deed Property on a Scrap of Paper Good Enough to Be a Valid Contract?

Last updated: May 2006

The following question was submitted to John Roska, an attorney/writer whose weekly newspaper column, "Q&A: The Law," runs in the St. Louis Post-Dispatch (Illinois Edition) and the Champaign News Gazette.

Question

My father’s neighbor says my father agreed to sell him the vacant lot that sits between their property. The only “contract” the neighbor has is a scrap of paper my father wrote on saying he’d deed the property over if the neighbor paid a certain amount. Neither my father nor the neighbor signed it. My father’s now gotten better offers for the lot, and would like to sell to someone else. The neighbor’s says he’ll sue if my father doesn’t sell to him. I say there’s no valid contract to sell the lot, so the neighbor has nothing to enforce. Does the neighbor have a case?

Answer

Even though Illinois law says land contracts should be in writing, and signed, your father’s neighbor may still may have a valid contract. The neighbor could have a pretty good case if he’s actually been paying for the lot.

Oral contracts—even to sell land—can be valid, but they just invite trouble. Unless things are pinned down in writing, people can argue about what was supposed to happen. And arguments over big ticket items like real estate tend to get serious.

As a result, Illinois, like probably just about every other state, requires land contracts to be in writing. The venerable Statute of Frauds says that contracts to sell land are not enforceable “unless such contract or some memorandum or note thereof shall be in writing, and signed by the party to be charged therewith.”

Besides the Statute of Fraud’s requirement of something in writing with one signature on it (the signature of the person who’d be sued), court cases have said that land contracts must identify the buyer and seller, identify the property being sold with some description, and state the sale price and terms.

The main thing lacking on the scrap of paper the neighbor has is your father’s signature. You might think that no signature means no contract, but naturally there are exceptions to the Statute of Frauds. The most important one says that a contract that doesn’t meet the Statute of Frauds requirements can still be enforceable if there’s been “partial performance.”

That occurs when the buyer or seller have done something that shows they’re holding up their end of a deal. By performing part of the agreement, they’ve gotten far enough along so that it would be unfair to stop and leave them empty handed.

The neighbor may be able to prove partial performance by showing that he’s been making payments based on the agreement he thought he’d made. In other cases, actually moving onto the property has been considered evidence of partial performance.

As lawyers say, proving partial performance “takes the contract out of” the Statute of Frauds. It turns an otherwise invalid contract into a valid, enforceable one.

The moral: do it yourself land sales are a bad idea. Pay a lawyer to do the contract and sale for you.

Helpful Organizations
The following organizations may be able to help you with foreclosure

Organizations 1 of 8 |

1.

Prairie State Legal Services, Inc. - Kankakee Office
191 South Chicago Kankakee, IL 60901 | View map

Phone: 815-935-2750
TTY: 815-935-2764
Toll-free: 800-346-2864

Languages: English
View Website

Prairie State Legal Services, Inc. provides free legal services in civil legal matters for low-income persons who have incomes below 125% of the federal poverty guidelines and senior citizens age 60 and older regardless of income.

Eligibility

Whether you are eligible for help from Prairie State Legal Services depends on the following factors:

  • You meet our income and asset guidelines, or are age 60 or older.
  • We have no ethical conflict of interest regarding your legal issue.
  • You live within the service area of Prairie State, or have a civil legal problem in one of the counties in our service area.
  • You meet the citizenship or immigration requirements established by Congress. It should be noted that immigrants who are fleeing domestic violence or trafficking are eligible for legal help regardless of immigration status in matters to address the abuse.
  • Government regulations do not prohibit Prairie State Legal Services from handling your type of legal problem.
  • You have one or more legal problems that can be addressed by PSLS attorneys and that fall within our established priorities.

Types of Legal Help

Due to high demand for our services, our staff is able to provide representation in certain areas of civil law designated as a priority. The following kinds of problems are illustrative of the cases that we may be able to help with (not an exclusive list):

High Priority Cases

  • Family Law: Protection from abuse or exploitation of domestic violence victims, elderly, children and persons w/disabilities; divorce and related relief for domestic violence victims.
  • Housing Law: Evictions and lock-outs; foreclosure defense; loss or denial of subsidized housing benefits; loss or denial of essential public utilities; substandard housing conditions cases that cannot be addressed by other agencies.
  • Health Care: Loss or denial of medical or nursing home care; loss or denial of medical benefits (Medicaid, Medicare).
  • Needs-based government assistance: Loss or denial of SSI, GA, TANF, VA, food stamps.
  • Other income benefits where alternative representation is unavailable: Loss or denial of unemployment insurance, Social Security Title II benefits.

Other Cases We May Handle

  • Family Law: Child support, custody, guardianship, visitation, parental rights, divorces for non-domestic violence victims.
  • Housing: Rent issues; security deposits; unit size; discrimination.
  • Education: admission, expulsion, special education & related services.
  • Health care and people with disabilities: powers of attorney and other health care documents; discrimination and reasonable accommodations.
  • Income or benefits: overpayments of government assistance; health insurance matters; employment issues.
  • Consumer Law: Bankruptcy or other debt relief; consumer fraud; protection of exempt income and assets; unfair debt collection practices; repossession; contract defenses.
     

View current federal poverty levels

Feedback

We welcome your comments and suggestions

User Survey - Please take a moment to fill out our User Survey to help us to provide better service.

Please do not email legal questions or information about your problem. We will not answer legal questions or provide legal assistance. You can find referrals to legal organizations that may be able to help you by clicking here.